Click to see our Amazing Spider-Man Comic Books Price Guide!

Click to see our Amazing Spider-Man Comics Price Guide!

Comics and Collectibles Free Appraisal

by Dean
(Canada)

Requested a comics and collectibles free appraisal and wanted to share my thoughts.

Process was simple to do after following instruction videos. Fast response and Ashley was a pleasure to deal with!

Comments for Comics and Collectibles Free Appraisal

Average Rating

Click here to add your own comments

Aug 11, 2025
Rating

Appraisal NEW
by: Anonymous

Thank you for a very quick and appraisal, Good communications.

Aug 07, 2025
Rating

Quick and supportive response
by: Anonymous

I was delighted with the speedy and supportive service provided- within half a day I had gotten usedul feedback to support selling my collection and appreciated the knowledge and suppoet offered. Great service and great company!

Jul 31, 2025
Rating

I would definitely use them again
by: Anonymous

I contacted them they contacted me right away in the same day within hours. They're legit people that tells you the truth that helps you out and gives you information to point you in the right direction where you need to go!!! I would definitely use them again

Jul 23, 2025
Rating

Appraisal Help for Vintage D&D Books
by: Anonymous

Super helpful and quick to respond. Even though they were not interested in buying what I had, they took the time to let me know it's value. Awesome people!

Jul 11, 2025
Rating

free appraisal plus friendly and quick service
by: Anonymous

Thanks Ashley for your appraisal!!! Not only were you extremely friendly but you provided me with an immediate response. Thank you for saving me time and money! 10/10 would recommend this service to anyone!

Jul 11, 2025
Rating

amazing feedback and quick response
by: Anonymous

I sent over some comics and they immediately got back to me on what each item would be worth. It was great getting an appraisal and feedback which would normally cost a lot of money! Highly recommend this to anyone looking to sell any comic from
their collection or in general. Great service and highly recommend using this for any comic appraisal! Much appreciated!

Jul 10, 2025
Rating

Great, honest service
by: Joe

Hello!

Irecently dealt with Ash for an appraisal and he was fast and gave realiatic prices.

Thanks so much!

Joe

Jul 10, 2025
Rating

Great honest appraisals
by: Anonymous

Ashley reviewed my comics and promptly gave me a quote as to the value without any hassle. It was great working with her and I appreciate her honesty.

Jul 05, 2025
Rating

Quick Response!
by: Anonymous

Ash,
I appreciate your help!!!!:)

Jul 04, 2025
Rating

Excellent Service
by: Ben

Anyone looking to buy or sell vintage toys should check these guys out. Ashley gave me a free appraisal on over 50 items in less than a few hours. That speed and expertise combined is rare, and makes that makes this business, one to explore. Best wishes to all-Ben

Jul 03, 2025
Rating

Review
by: Anonymous

Comics and Collectibles gave me a free appraisal on D&D books I've had since childhood. Very nice of them and seems to be a great place to do business. Thank you

Jun 18, 2025
Rating

Great Comic store
by: Robert B.

Through my dealings with Ashley I was impressed by his professionalism and friendly, easy-going manner.

All the best in the future of your business endeavors!

Jun 10, 2025
Rating

Helping me value my old D&D Book
by: Lance K.

Ashley assisted me in valuing my D&D books from the 1970s and 1980s. She advised me on the best way to get the most value out of them. Thank you, Ashley!

May 30, 2025
Rating

Great assistance!
by: Alicia H.

I’m in the process of selling my late husband’s very large collection of vintage D & D (and others!) RPG games and books. After selling a couple of shipments, I wanted to make certain I was getting a fair price, so I called Ash for help. He was so nice and helpful, and very prompt getting back to me with solid, fair pricing.

Thank you so much for your assistance!

May 29, 2025
Rating

Working with Ashley
by: Anonymous

Ashley was very responsive and easy to work with. Although we didn't reach a deal he was straightforward and a pro.

May 27, 2025
Rating

Assistance with GI Joe lot
by: tacenator

Ash was quick to respond and gave me valuable advice on how to deal with my GI Joe sale.
Thanks to him and the folks at this website!

May 04, 2025
Rating

Recent Purchase
by: Anonymous

I just received the CGC 9.8 Red Hulk #1 and I am very pleased with the comic as well as how it was packed for shipment.

May 02, 2025
Rating

Appraisal
by: Pattie Ferguson

This is my first time getting anyone to appraise my collection of The Walking Dead. Out of all the websites to deal with, I chose comics and collectibles. Ash, the representative for that company was excellent to work with. He responded very quickly to my email and gave me an appraisal the very next day! Seeing his picture and knowing that he is a legitimate person to deal with, gave me an extra sense of peace.
I couldn’t have asked for a better company or representative to deal with.
I highly recommend comics and collectibles to anyone who wants a quick and honest answer!

May 01, 2025
Rating

Happy with Transaction
by: Bart

Ashley and Sean were easy to deal with. Prompt communication and offered me a fair value for my comics. They were very accommodating to meeting if that was a more convenient way to conduct our business. I would highly recommend them if you are looking for a stress free transaction.

Bart
St. Catharines, ON

Apr 30, 2025
Rating

Misleading values
by: Anonymous

My D&D set is listed on the site for as much as $3500 with an average price of $2000 -- the dice alone are listed at up to $1000 -- but after I sent photos for an appraisal I was offered $300. Not sure whether their listed values are way off, or it's just a lowball offer.

Editor's reply:

As we explained, the damage to your box (repaired by archival tape) and the current state of the market means your set will sell for between $600 and $750. We wish you luck with your sale.

Apr 28, 2025
Rating

Sold items
by: Daniel Sawyer

There was no pressure on me if we did not come to agreement no pressure to sell would sell again but he lives to far away dan

Apr 25, 2025
Rating

Great communication and approachability!
by: Scott

I offered up a lengthy list for appraisal and I got a very prompt, candid response about my collection - they were very honest and upfront about not only the value but also what expenses there are when selling a large collection. Thanks again for your pricing of my books!

Apr 14, 2025
Rating

good appraisal
by: Elmer

You guys were excellent. I'm sorry we couldn't agree on a price, but you guys were the best. Thank you!

Mar 30, 2025
Rating

Very helpful appraisal
by: Kwd

Ashley was very thorough and helpful in helping me with appraising my set of old comics. He made an offer for the set and the communication was clear and with immediate response times. I really appreciated the help in navigating the best decision for my situation.

Mar 29, 2025
Rating

Quick and knowledgeable
by: Stan Bray

Asked for an Appraisal of Vintage Toys and was quick to respond. Although they did not buy my items, they sent an appraisal of my collection and was very helpful identifying each piece. Would definitely recommend and will use again.

Mar 26, 2025
Rating

Perfect
by: Anonymous

Ash gave me the information I wanted in a very short Time.
Very good communication, very kind person.
Would highly recommand

Mar 25, 2025
Rating

Very fast
by: Anthony jarc

Thank you for helping me, your help was fast and the process not complicated at all.

Mar 24, 2025
Rating

Quick service
by: John Piper

Extremely fast response for appraisals. Well worth a visit.

Mar 24, 2025
Rating

Honest and Experienced
by: GR

Ashley helped me sell my comic book collection and made the process easy and uncomplicated. He was always quick to respond when I had a question and was informative and above all, honest. Highly recommended!

Mar 12, 2025
Rating

Very Helpful and Fast
by: Anonymous

Ash and their team got back to me same day asking for photos and got me the estimate by the next morning. The estimate matched my other research and was very helpful for confirmation.

Feb 26, 2025
Rating

Valuation
by: Donna Conaghan

Sent approx 20 photos for advise and valuations
The response was so quick, no hanging about for days wondering.
Really was ab exceptional service and very honest
Valuations inc advise on where to sell locally.
Huge thanks to Ash as the communication back and forth was timeless.👏👏👏

Jan 30, 2025
Rating

fast reply, accurate pricing
by: Vihaan Guleria

Really good website, the owner is fast to reply and gives accurate pricing. One of the best websites i have discovered! good customer service!

Jan 30, 2025
Rating

fast reply, accurate pricing
by: Vihaan Guleria

Really good website, the owner is fast to reply and gives accurate pricing. One of the best websites i have discovered! good customer service!

Jan 28, 2025
Rating

Appraisal
by: Emil Coccaro

Ash was FABULOUS! I received an appraisal in only a few hours. His review of my collection was on point and extremely helpful. He is extremely conversant with the industry and very approachable.

Jan 20, 2025
Rating

Great resource and easy to work with
by: Anonymous

Ashley and his team were great to work with. Incredibly professional and knowledgeable and always timely in responding. I would definitely work with them again!

Jan 06, 2025
Rating

Great people
by: Chip

Had the pleasure of working with Ashley on getting some of my comics appraised. Being new to the collectable game he took time to make sure I understood everything I needed to know. Very happy with all my new knowledge and would definitely go to him again for any and all of my needs and/or questions. Highly recommend and I'm very happy.

Nov 22, 2024
Rating

Comic book appraisal
by: Anonymous

Find their website easily and got a response very quick, the response had a simple method to list my list of comics.
The response to my list was also very quick with a short simple answer - thanks guys

Nov 12, 2024
Rating

Really Helpful
by: Mitch

Helped me a lot on my road to understanding value of my comics and gave me impartial advise on where I can start looking to sell.

Thank you again Ashley!

Nov 04, 2024
Rating

Rating
by: James Akers

What a great service they provided. Not only did he give me a real value on my loose HeMan figures, but also went the extra mile and gave me the list of names of every character and individual value and what I should price them at. I highly recommend them.

Aug 16, 2024
Rating

Review
by: Anonymous

fast response

Aug 13, 2024
Rating

by: Ashley

Thanks so much for your feedback -- it was a pleasure to help you.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Feedback on Our Free Appraisals.

Click here when you're ready to sell your collection!